My EcoVadis Score Was Lower Than Expected. What Are My Next Steps?

Got a lower-than-expected EcoVadis score? Here's what to do in the next 48 hours to turn your scorecard into a focused, high-impact reassessment plan:

1. Pause to reframe the issue as a data challenge.
2. Conduct a forensic analysis of your scorecard.
3. Make a go/no-go decision on a Scorecard Inquiry.
4. Prepare a brief for management.
5. Build a prioritised reassessment strategy.

Step 1: Take a Breath and Triage

Receiving a disappointing score is frustrating, especially after investing significant time and effort. The first step is to pause and reframe the situation. A low score rarely means your company has bad intentions; it almost always means there was a breakdown in how your company's sustainability management system was documented and presented.

Think of it as a data problem, not a moral one. This mindset shift helps you move from feeling defeated to feeling empowered to solve a specific, technical challenge.

Step 2: Conduct a "Forensic Analysis" of Your Scorecard

Your scorecard is the most valuable tool you have for a comeback. It contains the exact feedback you need to improve. Here’s how to analyse it:

Start with Your "Improvement Areas"

This section is your personalised to-do list from the EcoVadis analyst. It details the specific weaknesses that impacted your score. Group them by theme (Environment, Labour & Human Rights, Ethics, Sustainable Procurement) to identify which areas need the most attention.

Diagnose the P-A-R Weakness

For each improvement area, determine if the gap lies in your Policies, Actions, or Results (P-A-R). This tells you what kind of solution is needed.

• Policy Gap: The analyst couldn't find a formal, documented commitment.
• Action Gap: You have a policy, but couldn't show you've implemented it.
• Result Gap: You have policies and actions, but no performance data.

Forensic Analysis Micro-Checklist

As you review your evidence, check for these common failure points:

• Scope fit: Does the document explicitly cover the rated entity/site?
• Formality: Does it have a title, owner, issue/review date, and approvals/versioning?
• Deployment (Actions): Do you have training logs, sign-offs, roll-out communications, or audits?
• Results: Are your KPIs presented with units, boundaries, the reporting period, and at least a 2-year trend?
• No Franken-PDFs: Don’t merge unrelated files into one PDF; it's the fastest route to rejection.
• Evidence lives in the file: Don’t rely on external links—include the proof directly in the document you upload.

Step 3: Make the Go/No-Go Decision on a Scorecard Inquiry

Use a Scorecard Inquiry only after your run this quick test:

1. You can cite the uploaded document name and the exact page number containing the evidence you believe was missed.
2. Your question is specific (e.g., about methodology or its application), not a general disagreement with the score.
3. You are not attempting to submit new documents or information via the inquiry.

If you respond TRUE to all three of these, go ahead and file an Inquiry. EcoVadis allows up to 15 precise questions per inquiry.

Remember, it’s a free clarification tool, not an appeal process.

Step 4: Prepare the 6-Slide Management Brief

Someone has to tell the management the "bad news". The good news is that a low medal (or no medal) is the perfect burning platform to get management on your side. By presenting a clear, solution-focused narrative, that doesn't just present the problem, but also a plan, you can offer them a path towards a higher rating. Structure your brief something like this:

• Slide 1: Score at a glance: Overall __ /100; Theme deltas E __, L&HR __, Ethics __, SP __ compared to previous scorecard.
• Slide 2: Why it happened (P-A-R): __ Policy, __ Actions, __ Results gaps; __ rejected docs; __ out-of-date items.
• Slide 3: Business risk: __% of revenue linked to customers referencing EcoVadis; current medal: __; implications for tenders/visibility.
• Slide 4: The 90-Day Plan: Define your list of Quick Wins, Strategic Projects, and KPIs to build.
• Slide 5: What I need: __ FTE weeks, budget €__, approvals from __, cross-functional support from __.
• Slide 6: Key Milestones: Outline the timeline: Scorecard inquiry submission (if applicable) → evidence fixes → targeted reassessment window.

Rule of thumb: if it doesn't move a weighted theme or close a P-A-R gap, it doesn't go on the 90-day plan.

Step 5: Build Your Reassessment Plan

With your analysis and internal approvals complete, the final step is to build a structured plan.

Prioritise Your Actions

You cannot fix everything at once. Use the Action Plan Prioritisation Matrix from your 48-hour triage to categorise your "Improvement Areas" into Quick Wins and Strategic Projects. This ensures you focus your effort where it will have the biggest impact.

Create a Continuous Improvement Engine

A one-time push is not enough. To truly improve, you need a systematic process. For a complete guide on turning this analysis into a long-term strategy, you must read our main Hub post: How to Improve Your EcoVadis Score.

Need an Answer?
Is there a part of the EcoVadis process you're stuck on? Click here to submit your question, and it could be featured in a future edition of The Answer.